Wednesday 31 October 2018

DHADI DARSHAN --- NOT THE SOLE PROJECT THAT WENT WRONG IN ODISHA




                                                                                                                         
“Until justice rolls down like water and righteousness like a mighty stream.”
― Martin Luther King Jr.

Justice is the elixir of life. Craving for justice perhaps was one of the primary motivations for man to create the State. Preamble to our Constitution mentions about our solemn resolve to constitute our country to a sovereign socialist secular democratic republic and secure to all its citizens justice, liberty, equality and fraternity. Among the four primary obligations we have set upon ourselves and resolved to ensure; Justice has been assigned the top position.  Justice has to be ensured in social, economic and political spheres.

People seek Justice --- social, economic and political-- from the Courts. Courts are our Temples of Justice; they secure our freedom, protect us against injustice. We seek its protection against onslaught on our liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship; we pray to court to ensure that we enjoy equality of status and opportunity. While I write, the working of the highest Court of the state—the High Court--- stands severely affected for two months due to strike by lawyers who reportedly are aggrieved over alleged police excess in some matter. A matter of this nature, involving a citizen and the police, comes under the purview of state’s executive organ. The impasse, however, continues. For a long time, courts in Sambalpur are unable to function normally, again over certain grievances. Here again the state has been witnessing the impasse that has been causing untold misery to the litigant public.

A word about the situation in the area of economic justice would be relevant. A review of the implementation of the Forest Rights Act,2006 --- a law in force for 12 years -- till August, 2018 indicated that out of 5,362 Community Forest Resources claims received by government, 3,525 claims have been settled and Titles had been distributed for 2,826 cases. Despite the district level committee being headed by the Collector, it takes long time to hand over Titles to the claimant villagers. Out of 2,826 Titles distributed, demarcation had been done only for 300 Titles in the concerned villages. Sadly, correction of record has not been made even in one case so far. Analysis of individual claims under the Act is also indicative of the lack of dispatch.  Forest Rights Committees (FRCs) filed 6,10,219 individual claims. District Level Committees (DLCs) headed by Collectors disposed of 5,78,265 individual claims. DLCs rejected as many as 1,46,107 individual claims.  4,20,992 individual titles have been distributed. Records of Rights have been corrected only for 1,31,483 individual titles. Though the Act mandates that titles can be given up to 10 acres, the average extent of land per title is only 1.5 Acres.

Urbanisation in Odisha has remained slow. Around 85% of its people still live in villages. By itself it may not be a conclusive indicator of the state's slow development. With a predominantly rural population, it is still possible to have an affluent economy with the state's population living mostly in prosperous villages. If, however, most of the villages continue to be poor with little productive activities, it indicates inadequacy of development.  As of now, public sector Banks have 1493 Branches in the state's rural areas and the private sector Banks have 181 Branches. The two Rural Banks in the state have 839 Rural Branches and the Cooperative Banks have 170 such branches. Total number of Rural Branches in the state therefore is 2683 out of the total of 5108 Branches in the state of all the Banks put together. The state has 6799 Grama Panchayats and about 4600 of them, as of now, have no presence of Banks in their area. This is an indicator of the low level of economic activity in the greater part of our rural area. On the other hand, liquor is available everywhere, in plenty, even in unbanked Grama Panchayats. We can ill afford not to take notice of this harsh reality. It is a matter of concern that a Regional Party in power for close to two decades has failed to bring in wealth into the bulk of the state’s households. It seems its people has been managed to be in peace with poverty with small state-sops.

With the constitution of the   Mahanadi Water Disputes Tribunal the ruling Party and its Supremo seem to be resting on laurels and the issue of the mighty River’s untapped irrigation potential seems to have been decently buried. Following the wide-scale hue and cry over inaction of the state government in utilising the Mahanadi water downstream Hirakud, there was an announcement that Government would build six Barrages on the River downstream Hirakud and twenty-two Barrages on different tributaries of the Mahanadi. And they seemed to have been happy that their responsibility on utilisation of Mahanadi water has been discharged with this announcement. The need of the state for irrigation through optimum utilisation of the Mahanadi water has hardly been appreciated. Nor is any concern discernible about the future of the Hirakud Irrigation system fifty years down the line. Will not the present command area of Hirakud and Delta Irrigation be severely compromised if the prevailing mindset of the government continues? We cannot ignore the relevance of new Dams in the Mahanadi. The issue of rehabilitation and submergence notwithstanding, Andhra Pradesh is going ahead with the mammoth Polavaram Project. We have hardly done anything in tapping new hydro potential. Three Barrages were contemplated on the Mahanadi between Hirakud and Sonpur to use the hydro-potential which could have been used as peak load power plants. Little seems to have been done in respect of the hydro potential of the Baitarani.

The lacklustre performance over the Mahanadi issue notwithstanding, Naveen Patnaik has reasons to be happy about what he has been able to achieve. He has successfully stalled a CBI investigation into the mining scam; Chit Fund investigation seems to have been buried and the BJD Supremo has reasons to claim that his Party’s incorruptibility stands vindicated. He has gone ahead with the State’s own schemes on Food Security and Health Insurance. He has promoted Hockey the way no one did before. Bhubaneswar is being publicised as the Sports Capital and at least, his core admirers believe it. He is focussed on his electorate and every effort is made to make him look as a transformational leader. In full-page advertisements of the state government published in national and local newspapers, pictures of a few major bridges inaugurated recently by him are shown with the Chief Minister as the sole pedestrian on the long-bedecked Bridges.

People of the state, who would have been eligible under the comprehensive health insurance scheme of Ayushman Bharat Yojana, seem to have been deprived of the advantages the scheme offers merely because the Odisha has not joined the scheme and has launched its own. The state scheme costs the state much more and gives much less to the clients; yet the state government has not heeded to the plea of the Prime Minister.

“Dhadi Darshan”, a system of visiting the Shri Jagannath Temple in Puri in queue was introduced without adequate discussion with the stakeholders. It led to widespread inconvenience and  resentment leading to widespread violence in the temple-city. The practice was hastily done away with leaving deep scars on the historic Baish Pahacha of the Temple and the psyche of millions of devotees. The government preferred to turn a Nelson’s eye to the safety of the Temple Treasure in the Ratna Bhandar even after knowing that the keys to the Bhandar have been missing. The first thing that should have been done with alacrity was to have a supervised entry to the Bhandar, take stock of the treasures found, checked the treasures with the list of inventories prepared some years ago and mounted a hunt for the missing treasure if anything was found missing. They preferred a Commission of Inquiry to ascertain the circumstances that led to the missing of the Keys.

Before the state is in a state of euphoria over World Hockey show beginning in Bhubaneswar, Sundari, the Tigress, bought by the state government at a huge price from a sister state, is on a killing mode and the second person is dead. Satakosia region now tense. In stead of the jungles of the Satakosia reverberating with tiger roar  as the state government had thought the progenies of Sundari and her partner would bring about, it now human anger the state government is to content with.

Biju Janata Dal and its Supremo would be perhaps facing the toughest political fight in the next Election not far away. Other Parties seem to be much better prepared this time than they ever were and detractors of the present regime are increasing every day.

****** 




No comments:

Post a Comment